Our second First Impression for
the month of February comes from Larry O’Donnell, my brother-in-law and
frequent guest poster. This is the first
page of his most recent WIP, a thriller titled THE PORTAL.
Chapter 1: The Release
It was one of those damp cold nights that only West
Virginia seems to get. It goes straight
to one’s bones and stays there at least until the sun comes back. I had
been asleep for about three hours when my dog, Ralph, alerted me to the sound
of rapping on my front door. Arming
myself with a five iron, I went to the door and flung it open. There at my feet was Derek Sanders, one of a
group of regulars who gathered on Wednesday and Friday nights for drinks at the
Jeff Davis bar in downtown Port Anthracite.
I usually attended these gatherings, although I don’t drink
anymore. It is my only regular social
activity, but I felt achy and the chilling weather decided me to go home after
work. Sanders was shivering in the cold
mist and mumbling incoherently.
“Jesus, Sanders, I nearly chipped your head back out to
the street.” As if I could hit anything
with a golf club. Instead of calling me
on it, he pushed himself back up into a sitting position.
“We opened the door.
One of them got out. We closed and
barred it. Too-late-to-stop-one.” Derek gasped out the phrases and then sat up higher
for a moment. A low congested cough was
the last audible sound he made as he fell over on his side in a fetal position.
“Sanders! Come on
buddy, wake up!” I couldn’t wake him and
it was apparent that he was no longer breathing. The last cough brought bright red frothy
blood out of his mouth. I felt for a
pulse and found none. Then I saw copious
amounts of blood from several other places and I knew he was beyond any help I
could give him.
A call to 911from the house of the Chief of Police
resulted in a flood of State Police cars, ambulance, Paramedics, some Firemen,
County Detectives, and Roy Biggers, the County Prosecuting Attorney. Fifteen minutes later, the County Coroner,
Doc Paxon, arrived.
Now, Roy and I do not get along, not even going back to
our time in High School. It’s nothing
specific, it’s just an oil and water thing.
We played on the same football and baseball teams but could never find
common ground on anything else. There
was no competition between us, no argument over a girl, just a deep seated
dislike of each other. Oddly, just as it
was when we played football, we could work together for a common goal but never
cross the threshold of the other’s home.
I’ll start with some small technical
details: The opening paragraph uses past tense for things that happened that night and present tense
for things that are always true. I think common practice would recommend
keeping to the past tense throughout. (ex: It went straight to one’s bones and stayed there at least until the sun came back.) There are also
some common nouns that shouldn’t be capitalized, such as high school, firemen, and county detectives.
I would hold back
explaining why the narrator hadn’t been to the bar with Sanders on this
particular night until the county prosecutor asks him. If they don’t get along, it might make for a
nice tension-filled moment later.
The cough with the frothy blood
should probably come in the paragraph while Sanders is still talking, rather than
when he has no pulse, and I would go for a more breathless feel to his words: “We opened … the door. One of ‘em … got out. Closed and barred it. Too late … to stop one.”
I might also like a hint of what’s
going on inside the narrator’s mind before everybody else arrives. He’s the chief of police, and a death on his
doorstep is going to activate the “business as usual” part of his persona, but
still – this is somebody he knows. Is he upset? Does he suppress it? Or, as
chief of police in a small town, is he used to seeing death and disaster befall
people he knows? Just a line or two would
help us bond with this character before the rest of the cast appears
in force.
Now, as one of Larry's CPs, I’ve read more of this. I wish I could
include the line where the county coroner questions the narrator about Sanders’s
last words and exclaims: “Did he mean the door? They opened the portal? Holy shit, were they crazy, drunk, or crazy
drunk?” But you can’t fit everything on the first page. ;) I know Larry’s got
a spooky thriller here, and beginning with a death on the police chief’s doorstep
is not a bad way to start.
Thanks, Larry, for sharing your first page! Please be sure
and stop by Mainewords today to check out Marcy’s critique of this same page.

7 comments:
Whoa--a lot is happening in this opening! And while I would keep reading because the whole "we opened the door and one got out" thing is freaky, this feels like it happens TOO fast somehow. The voice is very matter-of-fact, and there's nothing wrong with that. But when you pair that with some of the "telling" in the paragraph when he calls 911, I felt like the impact of this grisly death in the middle of the night ... was lost.
A few things: I'd rather be shown he's the Chief of Police than told it. If he's a cop--and he's worried enough about someone at his door to grab a golf club--wouldn't he grab his gun instead? And as a cop, I'd like him to have some thoughts about the dead man on his door step as he makes the 911 call. I want to SEE him making the call. I want to SEE these vehicles skidding into his driveway. I want to know his thoughts as this happens, especially when Doc gets out of his car and strides across the lawn. These are great opportunities to SHOW me these characters (including the MC), to paint a picture of them, and this WV setting, in my head so I can envision this story while it's happening. I think it's important to be patient and take the time to set this up properly, because it certainly sounds worth reading! Best of luck!
From a storytelling point of view, I really like this. As Dianne and Sarah have both pointed out, the premise of this story is clearly intriguing, and I too would read on.
From a writing stand point, there are some things that need a little work. As Dianne mentions, tense is one. Another is the way the dialog comes across. It feels stilted, and keeps getting interrupted by narration. I also agree with Sarah about the lack of showing when it comes to all these law enforcement officials showing up. There might be a legitimate reason you summarize all that, but I think you're missing an opportunity to show an exciting scene.
I agree with Matt, the revelation that the murder victim is found on the police chiefs doorstep is treated to matter-of-factly and therefore a missed opportunity for further intrigue. Otherwise, well done.
There's much to like here, and overall, the story seems compelling -- I would read on.
But f I were to pick a few nits:
-- Yeah, the tense thing. I'd stick to one, preferably past.
-- I agree with Matthew above about the dialogue. It could flow a little better uninterrupted. Also, ditto on the familiar "show, don't tell" advice.
-- Starting with the weather as the opening sentence. It's cliche and lends to a "It was a dark and stormy night" comparison. Not the comparison you want your opening line to evoke.
-- The MC getting woken up: another cliche that implies "rookie writer." I know -- it seems like a very logical way to begin; waking up in a strange place, starting the 'big day', coming out of a dream, getting woken up by someone pounding on the door, etc. But it's really overdone and trite. (and I've forced myself out of using it several times after having it pointed out, LOL).
But story-wise: Definitely sounds like something I'd really be interested in.
Oh, intriguing! You've already gotten good craft comments, so I won't add to those, but I did want to say that for me Story (yes, Story with a capital S *grin*) is king. I would keep reading. But a little polish would make it an even better read. :)
I love the premise of the story and the only thing I would add to the craft piece is to read for use of contractions. A lot of time phrases like he had or can not sound clunky when re-read and flow better as he'd or can't.
I think the premise is also very catchy and intriguing, but I agree with Sarah and Matt's comments. They said it better than I could've.
Post a Comment